Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Floyd WADA. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Floyd WADA. Sort by date Show all posts

24 April 2007

WADA do about L'EQUIPE?? BOYCOTT!!!

ZENfriends:

There comes a time when the people of a country must rise against the oppression...

Doesn't sound like we're talking about a Sports-newspaper? Well, in France the tradition to take to the streets is omnipresent, and with the latest scandal-ridden spew published by L'Equipe, the French journal that was the original sponsoring paper behind the Tour de France, the farce continues...

Floyd Landis, valiant and memorable victor of the 2006 Tour de France, has been spared no pain in the on-going witch-hunt produced by the following listed entities:

LNDD: the French Laboratoire nationale du dépistage du dopage;

WADA: the World Anti-Doping Agency;

USADA: the United States Anti-Doping Agency;

L'EQUIPE: French sporting journal.

My various in-depth articles have described in depth how each of these agents has individually failed to officiate over any process of drug-testing, based on what is happening to Floyd Landis.

See:

Part One: WADA do about Floyd???

Part Two: WADA do about Floyd???

Part Three: WADA do about Floyd???


As well as these other subsequent, sequentially-listed articles:

FLOYD GOES FREE under the Pound Doctrine (March 7, 2007)

How not to Laugh with Floyd... Landis (March 8, 2007)

WADA do about WADA? (March 21, 2007)

WADA do about the (Landis) Chain of Evidence? (March 21, 2007)

Pound's new CRUSADE against justice in SPORT (March 22, 2007)

WADA do about Strict Liability... (April 5, 2007)

WADA do about USADA??? (April 13, 2007)


WADA
has failed, the LNDD has failed, and the USADA also has; in its quest for success, the US taxpayer-financed Organization, has failed to protect the rights of a falsely-accused (so this legally-trained author believes) cyclist/athlete.

The ongoing case, slated for a hearing in two weeks, on May 14th, took a bizarre twist with the request by USADA for f
urther 'B Sample' testing of remaining Landis urine samples, using IRMS technology designed to discern exogenous testosterone.
(
Jacques de Ceaurriz, director of LNDD, Jean-François Lamour, and Colette Besson, president of CA; photo from French Gov't)

Any OBJECTIVE person may think, that with a Laboratory under the gun for past ... well 'shoddy' is the most scientific term I can think of... past shoddy work, with numerous errors at hand, well: that the USADA would have a compromise venue, another laboratory possessing a reputation of total integrity, to perform these 'longitudinal' studies, which could serve to allow a graphic display of Landis' naturally fluctuating Testosterone levels.

Didn't happen that way.

OH! Did I forget to mention, that the French l'Equipe has leaked each very prominent rider's result produced by LNDD? In every case presented to the Lab, in contravention (as to the Lab) of a WADA 'Code of Conduct', which places the strictest confidence on the Lab?

Here's what Netherlands attorney Emile Vrijman said about L'Equipe, writing about its collusion in the Lance Armstrong fiasco of 2005:

The investigator does not know how the research reports of the LNDD came into the possession of Mr. Ressiot, the journalist of L’Equipe. These reports however, must have been provided either by the LNDD, the Ministry or WADA, as WADA and the Ministry had received copies of reports drafted and sent by the LNDD. The investigator regrets the lack of cooperation of these three bodies. It is clear that only a thorough investigation within each of them might find the answer to this important question, that affects the confidence that athletes, ADO’s and the public are entitled to have in these bodies. (UCI Vrijman report, p.121: para 5.1)



So when l'Equipe published Monday (in FR), its most recent leak on the Landis case, its article was totally slanted towards erasing the memory of Landis' (as well as Lance Armstrong's) accusations of malfeasance:

"Floyd Landis, qui s'est évertué depuis plusieurs mois à décrédibiliser le laboratoire français, aura bien du mal, cette fois-ci, à user de cet argument : les nouvelles analyses, effectuées la semaine dernière et clôturées ce week-end, ont été réalisées en présence de deux experts désignés par le coureur américain, et de deux représentants de l'USADA."


[Floyd Landis, who has for several months lost all virtue in trying to discredit the LNDD, will have some illness, this time, to use the same argument again: these new analyses, which took place last week and finalized this last weekend, were undertaken in the presence of two experts designated by the American racer, and two representatives of the USADA.]


The article claimed that Landis' experts, as called-for in the WADA and USADA regulations, were to be allowed full and complete access to all aspects of the testing...

That is not what Floyd's named experts are claiming.

IF
... the world depends on one journalistic, European voice, for the source of the most important information from the world of cycling, that source IS the French l'Equipe;

IF
... the voice of that paper, its authority, its staff, is rank with the festering wounds of losing circulation, odoriferous with the pus of leaks, incapable of registering right from wrong, whether by potentially paying for information or providing a government sponsored and sanctioned violation of the WADA CODE and the ISL Code of Ethics;

IF
... the accusing French laboratoire in which Floyd Landis has been 'found abnormal in ratio of Testosterone to Epitestosterone', has failed in prior occasions to uphold standards, the failure of which is potentially a violation;


Then the boycott of l'Equipe should be organized, its reporter Ressiot should be dismissed, as a call to the sensibilizing of the sport to the science that is not as far into the cutting-edge as certain Pounds, or de Ceaurriz' (Director of the LNDD) might have indicated.

And the implementation of the investigation that would decide on a sudden, necessary dis-accreditation of the French LNDD lab should be initiated by WADA, as requested already by two Olympic Federations, the
President of the ASOIF, and the President, IOC Athletes Commission, whose letter was a forceful but neglected request to WADA to rectify the errors of LNDD.

Please consider:

Ending Floyd's career is only justifiable if he was doping.

Ending the careers of reporters who buy or repeatedly acquire leaked confidential (think of YOUR doctor's records?!!) information, and their associated 'Confidential info Dealers/Leakers located variously in French governmental divisions, or in world-renowned Intergovernmental or international non-governmental organizations (WADA, USADA or UCI), is a much more noble goal.

Ending ambiguity, as seen in many articles of WADA's several controlling documents, is also the worthiest task ahead, for parties that represent the falsely, or 'inacurately' accused,such as the Alan Baxters of the world, or Floyd Landis.


When the Police need to be policed by those who are 'protected', then the wobbling imbalance may be too gone, too radically far to re-direct.

WADA
already has signs of Roid-rage and overexertion, as directed now by Dick Pound, and (if rumours are true) to be directed by the French Minister of Sport Jean-François Lamour after November 2007.

Due to its haste to install itself as the top-pissing wolf in the Sports Forest... its future is now cast in doubt, as Machiavellian aspects, similar to the Bush-invasion of Iraq, now are riding Floyd Landis into a clear contest of evidence, of will and political support.

Floyd needs your objective and clear opinions.


COURAGE, Floyd - Champion of the Tour de France 2006

ç*””*”*”*ç*””* ZENmud *””*ç*”*”*””*ç


02 March 2007

Part One: WADA do about Floyd???

IF Floyd rode under the IOC Medical Rules...

This is the First of a three-part article looking into the supranational legal effect of the World Anti-Doping Agency, its CODE covering doping analysis, and its effect on the cyclist Floyd Landis.

Click here for Part II, and Part III

I have questions about the rôle played by the WADA CODE, and its relevence to the ongoing battle between Floyd Landis, and the USADA, WADA and the Tour de France. I began this article by accident, when I read a clause in the IOC Medical CODE (excerpted from a paper by Lauri Tarasti, below, further citations sought), relating its procedures when existing evidence points towards a positive Testosterone/Epitestosterone (T/E) ratio, and the mandated steps before announcement of findings.

These questions relate to how Floyd Landis would have fared, in light of his positive T/E test in the 2006 Tour de France, and if he was treated under the WADA CODE as fairly as he would have if under Olympic authorities. (PHOTO credit: Bas Czerwinski - AP) There resides also the question of harmonization, which comes in the insertion of WADA as a new intergovernmental Organization (IGO).

To begin, certain passages of the IOC Medical CODE are emphasized the portions in italic, and in bold (and blue) italic, at the heart of this pertinent and vital paragraph:

2. IOC Medical Code, Chapter II:

The presence of a testosterone (T) to epitestosterone (E) ratio greater than six (6) to one (1) in the urine of a competitor constitutes an offence unless there is evidence that this ratio is due to a physiological or pathological condition, e.g. low epitestosterone excretion, androgen production of tumor, enzyme deficiencies. In the case of T/E higher than 6, it is mandatory that relevant medical authority conduct an investigation before the sample is declared positive. A full report will be written and will include a review of previous, subsequent tests and any results of endocrine investigations. In the event that previous tests are not available, the athlete should be tested unannounced at least once per month for three months. The results of these investigations should be included in the report. Failure to cooperate in the investigations will result in the sample being declared positive.



Is there harmony, between IOC MC-Ch.II and existing UCI Rules? Meaning: did Floyd enjoy any longitudinal testing that would, as is mandatory under the IOC Code above, serve to show a “physiological or pathological condition”?

If not, why are the IOC and WADA not in harmony on this issue?

The matter involves the documentation of International Standards for Testing, and International Standards for Laboratories, hopefully to be the focus of a second essay in the near future...

Does IOC trump WADA?

Not according to WADA... its Code, in sub-Article 20.1 et seq., manifest an obligation on the IOC to conform with the WADA Code, International Standard(s), and Best Practices. Yet if the WADA CODE (and International Standard for Testing) does not go as far as IOC already did, as found in the sequence reproduced above, should not WADA rectify the existing ambiguity by adopting the more stringent IOC standard?

If WADA had the supplementary testing requirement as part of its controlling documents, what would have been undertaken, to supplement the findings of Professeur de Ceaurriz' laboratoire, in the Floyd Landis Tour de France case?

A conference on updating the WADA Code will take place in late 2007. If issues discussed here are not addressed for inclusion in the WADA Code, or in the International Standards for Testing, it would reinforce certain perceptions that exist that WADA exists to satisfy governmental and political needs more than those of the competitive world it governs.

I suggest that WADA, if actually possible under the vitriolic leadership of Dick Pound, absolutely must strive to reinvigorate its CODE.

The CODE is a document requiring massive re-writing:

  • to harmonize its mandate; and,

  • introduce the requisite essentials that form objective and fair legal bases.

Balancing its quasi-legal system to afford more particular rights to the world class athletes in all sports, who undertake repetitive blood and urine tests, must be the goal. Those rights are not to provide any advantages to athletes – those rights are to receive transparent, exemplary science implementation, and guarantee confidentiality in the Results Management phase.

Even more severe, is a growing perception that the structure and inter-relationships between WADA, National Authorities and International Federations is not healthy or conducive to the fair administration of justice through private arbitration.

This indictment is not against WADA in the aggregate: it is specifically against its current President, Mr. Richard Pound, of Canada. Growing evidence serves as proof that, under his 'guidance', WADA has failed to maintain its penultimate, impartial and neutral rôle.

What's wrong with WADA? The GRAND CANYON in missing WADA rules coverage:

A humongeous chasm, wider than the Grand Canyon, exists in the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) in its efforts to harmonize and give structure to the fight against doping; that canyon is revealed as a fundamental failure to address a critical component in the testing process: a fatal flaw that must be addressed before WADA-associated Anti-Doping Organizations destroy other athletes' careers through negligence or malfeasance.

'Other athletes', in the sense that as you read this, Floyd Landis, 2006 winner of the Tour de France bicycle race, awaits his USADA hearing in May 2007, on the damning 'evidence' that he was 'positive' for an imbalanced testosterone/ epitestosterone (T/E) ratio: the tests that are used to measure possible exogenous intake of a doping product.

That critical, overlooked component is the lack of disciplinary control expressed in the WADA CODE regarding Doping Control Authorities, and/or their authorized laboratory(-ies), concerning their procedures and adherence to scientific standards. This article addresses the salient points revealed within the WADA “World Anti-Doping CODE” 2003.

Short tour down WADA-MEMORY Lane...

WADA was founded in 2003, inaugurated after the prior years had demonstrated doping corruption in many world sports not limited to cycling: the top of the International Olympic Committee was rocking from financial and influence-peddling scandals, and cycling offered its own “Affaire Festina”, which rocked the 1998 Tour de France, after a Festina team trainer had been arrested at the Belgian/French border, in a station wagon full of EPO and other illegal medications.

The birth of WADA in 2003 begat the subsequent acceptance of its CODE, which had been promulgated “...to advance the anti-doping effort through universal harmonization of core anti-doping elements. It is intended to be specific enough to achieve complete harmonization on issues where uniformity is required, yet general enough in other areas to permit flexibility on how agreed anti-doping principles are implemented.”

Considered means; noble ends. Ignoble failure.

It is this article's contention that WADA's mission: 'to achieve complete harmonization on issues where uniformity is required...' is a sword with two sharp edges, and regarding which WADA has failed drastically in the achievement.

Clearly, the WADA CODE indicates what happens when any athlete has been tested positive; its Articles 7 through 11, (some 15 pages), specifically fix the processing of Sample Specimens, and consequential punitive steps. [NB: words in italics most often denote official language of the CODE.]

Yet the CODE itself does not elaborate how a laboratory becomes accredited, establishes its finding(s) and shall comport itself, in: maintaining state-of-the-art scientific testing apparati; objective performance (and auditable) criteria to be able to test Sample Specimens properly, and proper, confidential submissions of test data, that ensure the transmission of such results to the appropriate receiving Anti-Doping Organizations (ADO).

Clearly, how a laboratory produces the results that announce or reveal legitimate doping incidents, or false accusations that result from bad scientific processing, illegal tampering or simple negligence, must be held to as high a standard as WADA can expect from its captive audience – athletes the world over. The WADA CODE is a two-edged sword that now only cuts deep on one edge.

This dichotomy appears to be a failure for WADA, and its CODE.

WADA has demonstrably failed to provide, as its mission requires, a standard for harmonization and balance in the upholding of its rules. The applicable introductory paragraph of the CODE, regarding its INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS, conditions that: “Adherence to the International Standards is mandatory to ensure compliance with the CODE.” Yet how is such a simple assertion backed? Where are the sticks and carrots? Within the CODE, there are none, as will be revealed in Parts II and III of this article.

The WADA CODE certainly offers a great deal of specificity as to Athletes, as well it should. It covers so thoroughly nearly all aspects of procedures and results management reporting, as well as appeals regarding sports-doping, that the omission of any balancing regulations to uphold laboratory standards and accreditation stands out as brightly as would the Colorado River, gleaming away down in that ... Grand Canyon.

Yet the Laboratories serve as the front line against doping: the most critical component of the Doping Control phase. In an official document that even devotes an article (Art. 16) to the doping of animals (horses, one presumes), one would expect to read how WADA stridently regulates the laboratories that produce the AAFs against athletes such as Floyd Landis.

However, the WADA CODE does not define terms like 'Laboratory', 'accredited Laboratory', 'Testing Laboratory' or 'Testing Procedures' in any way, as THE critical component of Doping Control.

Links to Part II or Part III

ç*”*”*””*ç”*”*ZENmud”*””*ç*”*”*””*ç”

05 April 2007

WADA do about Strict Liability...

Warning: if anyone you know is a world-class competitor, nay! A CLEAN world-class competitor...

One who follows strict performance-based eating habits, and is exceptionally dedicated to their training programs and clean medical training assistance: beware!

Even if that person is as humanly 'perfect' as possible, morally, physically, and in the performance of their sport, they would still have no guarantee that his or her sports-career will end with their accolades intact, due to one small, grave situation.

They do NOT have to dope, to be convicted of doping.

At the dining table, or through someone offering them anything to drink; the wrong purchase of over-the-counter medications or sport-diet supplements, all these 'inputs' could be damning the competitor, whether through innocent or malicious means, such as being 'doctored' by third-party intervention.

The Athlete you know could have, for example, won the Tour de France through superhuman, heroic efforts, and have that performance validated by seven different daily tests that affirm his lack of doping.

However, given any 'positive' result from a doping test, even if the source could be determined; say, peanut butter sent as a birthday present by an Alabama cousin, perhaps: that positive-testing Athlete would face the worst scandal of their young, over-achieving lifetime... Oooops: but wait!

If we were talking about the 2006 Tour de France, and its winner, Floyd Landis, weren't there eight tests?

Yes...

In one of Floyd's eight 2006 Tour de France tests, he was found to have an 'uncharacteristically low' epi-testosterone level, which had the legal effect of skewing his Testosterone/epi-Testosterone ratio, which is a violation of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA)-approved test, and creating a 'positive' Adverse Analytical Finding (“AAF”, in the vernacular). Announced after his impressive victory of the 21-day race, Floyd has been facing since August 2006 the associated insinuations and loss of credibility we have been forced to associate with cycling.

Flaming the fires through statements to the press, from directors of the Tour de France, Dick Pound, the WADA President (see ZENarticles here, here or here) added prejudicial bias by stating that his title would be stripped, once the test findings were upheld. Statements such as these were unethically premature, by the Tour de France people, and border on the illegal, according to the WADA Code that Dick Pound's organization drafted, accepted and implemented worldwide.

Floyd Landis' earlier career, beside Lance Armstrong, catapulted the Texan towards several of his Tour de France victories at the US Postal / Discovery Channel Team. Graduating into his rôle as leader of the Swiss team Phonak, Floyd's career had never been tainted by any previously positive testing results. The test results for Floyd's 17th stage, mentioned above, were produced from Chatenay-Malabry, the French Laboratoire National du Dépistage du Dopage (LNDD).

Beyond having his team disbanded (PHONAK had witnessed a suspicious proportion of doping cases in its short, impressive history) Floyd saw his impressive career path placed on hold, while awaiting his case's resolution, in May 2007, with a decision by the US Anti-Doping Agency (USADA), and that decision may sanction him to a career-threatening two-year suspension.

The decision to be taken will be based on the evidence presented by the Athlete, and the sporting world that 'indicted' him, via the US Cycling Federation.

Now this article has its own viewpoint, based on the author's cycling and legal experience, as well as his personal presence one hundred metres away from the finish line in Morzine, France, where Floyd raised his arms in victory, in achieving his amazing Alpine comeback.

Generations of French, and cycling fans globally, wanted to believe that how Floyd won was 'à l'eau claire', as they say... “On clean water”. The viewpoint here is that Floyd did win the Tour, and somewhere, somehow, in the poor performance of what should be near-sacred testing procedures, Floyd's urine was found 'positive'.

At this point the overarching problem that was revealed by Floyd's case, after extensive analysis of his situation, are the disparate and biased sports-doping rules implemented by WADA. It is clearly delineated in the new micro-managed WADA world, that Athletes are held to a standard far beyond that to which their accusers – the Laboratories – must adhere.

The disparity? Only Athletes are held to the legal standard of Strict liability, in the context of any AAF. The term 'strict liability' is defined in Black's Legal Dictionary as:

Liability that does not depend on actual negligence or intent to harm, but that is based on the breach of an absolute duty to make something safe.

Which leads to 'absolute duty':

Absolute duty: A duty to which no corresponding right attaches.

In layman's wording? 'Zero tolerance'.

Remember Zero Tolerance, a gift to America from the Reagan administration, which allowed DEA agents to seize Charter sailboats that may have been leased a boat by groups who smoked some joints, all without the knowledge of the lessor? When perhaps as little as a single marijuana seed or stalk was found, after the boat was returned to its owner, that innocent person could face the loss of their boat, or investment, under this legal standard of strict liability.

But what if the Laboratory 'failed' in its work? What if a highly-technical scientific apparatus was mis-calibrated, or 'dirty', or leaked? Should not the accuser be held to the same legal standards? Should any hierarchy of laboratory technicians, their Directors and / or government ministries be allowed to dictate the outcome of events via either actual malfeasance or negligent casual operation of their testing facilities?

This is what Floyd and other Athletes face: there is no differentiation in WADA rules, between deliberate, excessively intentional 'doping', and innocent, accidental (careless or negligent) or malicious (deliberate 'poisoning' Athlete's food, or drink by adversaries or detractors) ingestion against one's proper morals. There are a sufficient number of cases already completed, that show that faith in such a presumption has 'destroyed' a good number of athletes' careers. One perfect example?

As a skier, the case of Alan Baxter is particularly sad, to this author. Alan, the first-ever British Alpine skiing Olypmic medalist, had purchased a Vicks Vapor Inhaler to counter his chronic nasal congestion, while attending the 2002 Salt Lake City events. Although sold under the identical mark as that which he usually bought in the UK (for chronic nasal congestion), its different formulation from that UK product cost him and England their first bronze medal, for his great race in the slalom!

He had never taken doping-medications, yet 'tested positive for methamphetamine'... by utilizing the wrong inhaler. This American variation contained no methamphetamine; however, one component has a similar chemical formula: no stimulative benefit, but it 'reveals' as meth under WADA-approved testing methodologies!

The fact that in the Landis case, “there is a 'there' there” (apologies to Gertrude Stein), by the one (out of eight) of his tests being positive, instantly suggested some prima facie presence of testosterone, or epi-testosterone 'doping' (or 'masking'), to the great majority of observers. Remember, however: Floyd's abnormal ratio stemmed from an ABSENCE: his epi-testosterone was very low. [NB: if this violation had occured under the previous IOC code, Floyd's solitary positive, against his seven other 2006 TdF negative results, may not have risen to the standard for declaring a positive.]

While the 'AAF result' from the French LNDD continues to damn Floyd Landis to a slow-death, through media obfuscation and repetition of often-misstated facts while attending this Spring's sport-arbitration, the legal situation with the LNDD who produced these results is not yet a significant matter: how the lab's analysis was performed could result in LNDD's actual suspension.

In the words of the WADA Code:

Code Article 3.2 Methods of Establishing Facts and Presumptions

3.2.1 WADA-accredited Laboratories are presumed to have conducted Sample analysis and custodial procedures in accordance with the International Standard for laboratory analysis. The Athlete may rebut this presumption by establishing that a departure from the International Standard occurred. If the Athlete rebuts the preceding presumption by showing that a departure from the International Standard occurred, then the Anti-Doping Organization shall have the burden to establish that such departure did not cause the Adverse Analytical Finding.

And how did WADA react to this unfortunate effect of its fight against 'doping'?


Other than its President repetitively spouting high invective, publishing prejudicial opinion pieces that violate the very essence of neutrality embodied in the WADA Code , it has done squat to rectify its imbalances that create a prison-camp mentality in the world-class world of sport.

[WADA has a late 2007 session scheduled, to re-examine the WADA Code in substantive detail.]

Yet, such is the life under 'strict liability' for the Athletes. How many more innocent victims must be, as may be Floyd, as certainly was Alan Baxter, scathingly scarred by the incriminations offered by labs and tests that are theoretically 'cutting edge', yet often-times not assured of the reliability that one presumes to be a standard, across the medical world?

Within the multilevel structure of WADA controlling documents (the Code, the International Standard for Laboratories (ISL) and the International Standard for Testing (IST)), the legal standard of 'strict liability' has only been applied to Athletes. Those entities that hold these Athletes' careers in their aliquots and Sample bottles, are known as the Signatories, and these include governmental authorities (which often include the accredited Laboratories), the International and National Sporting Federation authorities, as well as the Olympic and Paralympic authorities.

Athletes are 'only' members of WADA through their licenses to participate in their sporting Federations (such as FIS: the Federation International de Ski).

Why would WADA not subject its accredited Laboratories and other Anti-Doping Organizations to the same strict liability standards by which the athletes under this authority are judged? The following sub-Article of the WADA Code sets one applicable standard high enough...

Code Article 6 Analysis of Samples

Doping Control Samples shall be analyzed in accordance with the following principles:

[.....]
6.4 Standards for Sample Analysis and Reporting. Laboratories shall analyze Doping Control Samples and report results in conformity with the International Standard for Laboratories analysis.

And the International Standard for Laboratories (ISL), a derivative document enforced through adherence to the WADA CODE, also contains an interesting section:

5.4.5 Equipment
[.....]

5.4.5.3 General service equipment that is not used for making
measurements should be maintained by visual examination,
safety checks, and cleaning as necessary. Calibrations are only
required where the setting can significantly change the test
result. A maintenance schedule shall be established for items such as fume hoods, centrifuges, evaporators, etc, which are used in the test method.

5.4.5.4 Equipment or volumetric devices used in measuring shall have periodic performance checks along with servicing, cleaning, and repair.

5.4.5.5 Qualified subcontracted vendors may be used to service,
maintain, and repair measuring equipment.

5.4.5.6 All maintenance, service, and repair of equipment must be documented.

There is no directing language associated to this ISL, that forces WADA or its Anti-Doping Agencies (including accredited Laboratories) to operate at the same level of 'perfection' to which Athletes do. Meaning: there is no article in the WADA Code or corresponding Lab and Testing documents that creates strict liability against the Labs or their staff, for 'any deviation from the norm of perfection in testing and analysis', that allows the test results to be void for errors. In plain language: if a lab errs, or if a lab test such as Baxter's allows mis-identified chemical compounds to read as 'positive', should that Athlete face this unthinkably harsh penalty?

These problems bear review. As well, laboratories, especially the French LNDD, have notorious reputations for leaking information of a highly-confidential nature to various journals. The best example of this heinous practice falls against Lance Armstrong; the 2005 case of LNDD 'research' which was foisted off as 'proven', and that its 'bona fide' results established, that Armstrong 'was obviously doped on EPO in 1999'. There are no articles that proscribe automatic suspension of accredited laboratories that have serious problems maintaining mandatory confidentiality requirements.

It could happen, as such practice constitutes a violation of the ISL Annex B “Code of Ethics” Section 1:

1. Confidentiality

The heads of Laboratories, their delegates and Laboratory staff shall not discuss or comment to the media on individual results prior to the completion of any adjudication without consent of the organization that supplied sample to the Laboratory and the organization that is asserting the Adverse Analytical Finding in adjudication.

Why does WADA not hold its accredited laboratories to the same strict liability standards?

How could one envisage an inquisitorial system more perverse, than to have a laboratory that can produce 'innocent errors' or those based on negligence or malfeasance, or from unsatisfactory, yet approved, testing methods, while the Athlete bears all the shame, trauma and repercussions from an AAF against him or herself?

Should a Laboratory, which offers professional and amateur sport-career 'life or death' analyses to innocent Athletes, be held to any lower standard than those whom are to be judged by the results of their labwork?

There is no simple answer, other than the most naïve of responses: that no one could POSSIBLY suspect that a lab might operate, or might be directed to operate, with anything less than one hundred percent objectivity, and scientific perfection in the acquisition, storage and transport, processing, analysis of Samples and the subsequent related reporting of results: 'clean' or 'doped'...

The era of 'strict liability' for Athletes apart, and not for the Laboratories that 'indict' them, must end soon. Fairness, in the world of Sport, demands no less.

Why has WADA allowed this chasm to grow into a canyon of irresponsibility? Will a post-Pound WADA reassert the credibility destroyed by its current loud-mouth, hot-shot, Globetrotting President?


COURAGE!

ç*”*”*””*ç”*”* ZENmud ”*””*ç*”*”*””*ç


29 August 2007

WADA do about THE BIG PICTURE...

[Dear ZENers, this column has been CORRECTED and REVISED, with those actions shown in yellow text Sept. 7 2007]


Dick Pound, Floyd Landis, Patrice Clerc (nom?), Lance Armstrong, Jacques de Ceaurriz, Pierre Bordry, Emile Vrijman, Christian Prudhomme, Travis Tygart...

What do these nine names have in common?

They comprise three Americans, one Canadian, a Dutchman and four French... Two Tour de France victors, six blatantly biased detractors, and one objective investigator...

President of the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA: Pound); Winner of the 2006 Tour de France (Landis), President of Amaury Sport Organisation (Clerc), Seven-time Winner of the Tour de France (Armstrong), Directeur of the former Laboratoire nationale du dépistage du dopage (LNDD: de Ceaurriz – LNDD was recently 'Phoenix-ed' into the “Département des analyses”, under the French Anti-doping agency: AFLD), former Minister of the French Ministry for Youth and Sport (Bordry: scroll to EN translation of a FR press release from AFLD), former Director of the Netherlands Centre for Doping Affairs (Vrijman: download the PDF report), Directeur of the Tour de France (Prudhomme), General Counsel for the United States Anti-doping Agency (USADA: Taggart)...

Is it possible that they are a mixed salade: of manipulators, profiteers, victims and a white Knight, all due to the current RAGE against doping in cycling?

A righteous rage gone haywire, an ignoble pursuit of a noble goal, that is currently displaying the dark underbelly of the Anti-doping movement. Unarguably, the cleansing of cycling is overdue: cycling is one of the oldest sports of the modern era, a sport which, all admit, has experienced a long, historic system of doping, through seven generations.

The summer of 2007 fades: it is three months now, since Floyd Landis faced the modern equivalent of a medieval Inquisition against witches and heretics... his hearing for an Adverse Analytical Finding (AAF) 'found' by the French LNDD, pursuant to its tests (in its Châtenay-Malabry labs, a Parisian suburb) on participants of the Tour de France.

Floyd faced this armada of legal talent as David faced Goliath, armed with scientific data and legal analysis, paid for by thousands of believers who have chosen to fund his legal fight for legitimacy towards his victory of 2006.

This hearing was to be a slam-dunk against Landis, in the words of USADA attorney Richard Young, because of their evidence: "The science is solid."

What appeared to have actually happened, could perhaps be better described as a 'farcical comedy', 'charade' or 'fraudulent', perhaps, concerning the Prosecution's case.

Entering a world of anti-doping CODES, evidence and Standards for laboratories, 'aliquots', urinalysis, and the several hundreds of thousands of Euros in testing apparatus, the Prosecution was victim of itself, victim of a legal 'Rope-a-dope'. Only the Landis defense itself was able to do, what the Prosecution claimed they would: offer testimony of cold, hard science that was turned inside out, as the Defense showed time and again that the Châtenay-Malabry lab had failed in its duties to uphold worldwide scientific standards, of competence and confidentiality.

Past readers perhaps can recall this writer's angle on the affair, however it bears to be updated here: that there is a disbelief in certain circles of France, and elsewhere of course, that America could produce, in the talents of Lance Armstrong and Floyd Landis, eight consecutive victories in the Tour de France – without recourse to 'le Dopage'. These outstanding results by Landis and Armstrong relegated two national French heros, Jacques Anquetil, and Bernard Hinault, to glorified runners-up as five-time winners of the Tour de France (At least one of whom had admitted in his lifetime to ingesting 'assistance' of a chemical nature).

In the case of Lance Armstrong, the LNDD facility produced a dubious report, citing his alleged 1999 EPO use, concerning his remaining 'B Sample' urine specimens remaining from the 1999 TdF. 'Dubious', in that the testing that was achieved was 'novel', done under the guise of 'research', the use of which (for doping-control purposes) was illegal according to WADA rules and preceding IOC rules (WADA itself became an official entity in 2003: it had no jurisdiction over the 1999 samples that remained in LNDD custody), and of the bright-line separation of 'research testing' from 'doping control testing'.

In subsequent press articles, Dick Pound supported 'his' laboratory, the LNDD (Pound is far from being the most neutral mouth on the planet, as would befit the stature of his post as WADA President, and this Organization that he strove to legitimatize), and argued privately and publicly that the Union Cycliste International (UCI) should take action in light of this incriminating evidence against Armstrong.

Emile Vrijman, noted Netherlands sports law attorney and former Dutch Anti-Doping Agency Director, was mandated by the UCI to draft and produce an independent review of this 'case'.

The LNDD, and the French Ministry which controls LNDD, were never 'transparent' or accommodating, as to requests by Vrijman for documents and data concerning the 2004-2005 testing of the 1999 B Samples they retained. De Ceaurriz and Bordry, in harmonized language, denoted the impossibility of cooperation with an 'independent investigation' (Ie: not supported by a French Court's legal order to comply).

(see Vrijman report, pp. 50 (!), as well as 16, 20-22, 37, 47, 121, 126, 128)

It is not beyond objective suspicion, after publication of Vrijman's UCI-mandated report, or the timing of its release in May, 2006, to link the subsequent backlash by WADA President Dick Pound, due to its overly-negative contents, with certain following events affecting Landis and the TdF.

In apparent eagerness to avenge the Vrijman report, could cycling's heavyweights and the Gods of Anti-doping take barely conceivable steps, of which even the most lax observer could barely believe any of the actual evidence originating from what has become 'L'Affaire Landis'?

Jumping ahead, we pass over the Stage 17 victory by Landis, his epic solo breakaway, a majestic tour of assorted Haute-Savoie cols that ended in Morzine (where this author stood applauding, less than one hundred meters from the finish line).

Remember: Floyd was tested EIGHT times in the Tour, and seven of his A Samples were returned negative (four times prior to Stage 17, and three times afterwards).

We fast-forward past the critical urine test of his Stage 17 A Sample, that resulted in his positive AAF. Unlike other, typically suspicious announcements of TdF testing results being leaked by the French sporting newspaper L'Equipe, Landis' A Sample test result was announced publicly by the UCI, presumably in anticipation of publication in l'Equipe, of information that should have remained confidential until the confirming B Sample examinations had occurred.

Nevertheless, Floyd's test result was announced: apparently revealing an abnormally low level of epitestosterone, which skewed his T/E ratio (Testosterone/Epitestosterone) to 11:1, far beyond WADA's allowable 4:1 ratio.

The witch hunt began... and L'Equipe sold quite a few papers in those slow-sports-news days of August. Oh: you do know, of course, that the company run by Monsieur Clerc. ASO, owns both the Tour de France AND the Equipe journal? Interestingly for past readers, M. Clerc is a past French Tennis champion, and also former Director of the tennis club-stadium Roland-Garros, which was referred to in this column regarding the ITF's dispatch of tournament drug samples to Montreal's anti-doping facility. Read it here...

Hmmmm...

According to Floyd, he was contacted in August or September, 2006, by staff of the USADA, and offered the following 'option'. In return for a simple one-month suspension, atypically far shorter than the WADA CODE-proscribed two-year suspension for a first-time doping offense, Floyd would 'simply' have to help USADA, by turning in former teammate Lance Armstrong for his supposed doping practices, presumably while they were teammates at the formidable US Postal team during his historic streak of TdF victories.

Something in there, smacks of premeditation.

Something in there, tears asunder the threads of logic...

Could a laboratory in France, under its Ministry of Youth and Sport, which had been legally reamed by the Vrijman report only a month or two before the commencement of this 2006 TdF, seek revenge against Lance Armstrong through the person, the reputation, of one Floyd Landis?

The mind boggles... if true.

A simple recap:

1999 – 2005:
Lance wins seven consecutive Tours de France.

NB: Which relegated the five-time winners: two French, one Belgian, and one Spaniard to the new second-place tier...

2004-2005:
LNDD performs 'research' on samples from the 1999 TdF, for EPO, samples that then were five years old.

NB: previously, in 2000, LNDD published the results of similar research it had performed, on retained B Samples from the 1998 TdF. Those results were published in the scientific journal 'NATURE' in June, 2000: no athletes were known to have complained (where 28 of 102 tested anonymous B Samples showed evidence of r-EPO presence of over 0 – 3.7 IU per liter). It remains disturbingly unclear why LNDD did not choose to have its second analysis of the 1999 B Samples also published in NATURE or another scholarly journal: unless this 'research' was not scientifically sound.

23 August, 2005:
French journal l'Equipe published its scathing article entitled (FR) 'Le Mensonge d'Armstrong' (“Armstrong's Lie”), spun out of LNDD and French Ministry information, and pinpointing Lance Armstrong, and no other rider, as being one of six 'authors' of positively-tested 1999 TdF samples.

NB: Which instantly generated a thunderbolt of negative press against Lance, his teammates and his sponsors, one month after his glorious moment in Paris, on the Champes Elysées.

NB TWO: This article is no longer traceable by title on the 'l'EQUIPE website (Title above), but you can read about it here, in FR. Mostly listing reactions to the shock, of their scandalous false "testing".

Autumn, 2005 to Spring 2006:
Based on LNDD 'research' and the incriminations in the disparaging article published by l'Equipe, WADA adamantly suggested that the UCI initiate investigations as to the feasibility of disciplinary hearings against Lance Armstrong. WADA did so, knowing well that its suggestions were reproachable, per its own regulations.

UCI contravened, however, and announced its 'independent investigation' under the mandate issued to Emile Vrijman, attorney from the Hague, and former Director of the Dutch Anti-doping Agency.

WADA, LNDD and the French Ministry, who'd thus promoted 'convicting' Lance through the press (l'Equipe), in the intervening months began to withhold cooperation from the UCI-mandated report.

(Entities acting in concert, both together and independently, to trumpet the (Illegal) use of 'research results': See Vrijman, pp. 18, 26, 43, 55, 75, 94, 96, 101, 122, 128, 129)

May – June 2006:
The Vrijman report was published several weeks before the 2006 TdF;
Dick Pound reacted quite strongly in the press.

July 2006:
Floyd wins the TdF this one and only time, following a massive 'bonk' or loss of energy in Stage 16, and a gloriously historic, spectacular solo breakaway in Stage 17, along with a fantastic final Time Trial finish that sealed his lead, and gave him his victory over runner-up Oscar Pereiro.

(TdF trivia: no 'Grand Champion', between Armstrong, Indurain, Hinault, Merckx, Anquetil, EVER won a TdF in a year ending in xxx6)

Late July – early August 2006:
Floyd is pronounced as Positive for an excessive testosterone/epitestosterone ratio, from the Stage 17 A Sample test, a blow which subsequently forced his team, PHONAK (Swiss manufacturer of hearing aids), to withdraw from the cycling-sponsorship business.

September 2006:
Floyd alleged that he was approached by USADA staff, who offered him a 'sweetheart' deal if he turned informant against Lance Armstrong; according to Floyd he emphatically dismissed the idea of squealing.

Fall of 2006 – to Spring of 2007:
Floyd prepared for and submitted, in May 2007, his arguments and evidence before a panel of Arbitrators belonging to the American Arbitration Association, while facing USADA 'evidence' and hearsay testimony by Greg Lemond, also a three-time winner of the Tour de France.

Summer 2007:
Floyd and his supporters, WADA, the AFLD and USADA await a timely, reasoned written decision by the Arbitration Panelists. Once announced as coming out prior to the 2007 TdF, this article is publishing in the last week of August.

+ + + + + +

LNDD, the same lab that failed to conduct proper research, as required under the Declaration of Helsinki and the WADA ISL and IST documents, nevertheless used those results to damn Lance Armstrong in the court of public opinion.

LNDD, which declined to assist in the Vrijman investigation as to how those results became known to the reporter from l'Equipe, is the 'player' that provided the only positive test result against Floyd Landis in his long career, a positive result that, by the testimony of experts in the Arbitration Hearing, had exceptionally disregarded most of the scientific and investigative norms found in the WADA CODE and International Standard for Laboratories.

Is this evidence of a massive State machination, by elements under the Chirac government, to cut down – to surgically remove – from the glorious, illustrious annals of the Tour de France, the greatest living racer of all time (Armstrong)?

Is this evidence of intergovernmental and inter-Agency collusion, feeding on the blind ambitions of prosecuting attorneys and specious public servants? They who, at any cost, and damn the rules and regulations that control such efforts, lusted to create scandal and seed more doubt, in hopes of bringing down these two Americans victors, Lance and Floyd?

Were their hopes restricted to restoring the mythic 'Five Victories' threshold that stood so many years?

Or, conversely, maybe perversely, is this case merely a publicity stunt? A stunt that simultaneously increases awareness and thus financial support for the Anti-doping entities that are growing fat on increasingly available public money, and demeans the efforts of the UCI Federation, through serial victimization of presumptively-innocent, distinguished World Class Cyclists?

Should an Athlete like Floyd Landis, who had to raise legal funds exceeding $2 million to fight a case against a lab result generated by a facility with a litany of seriously egregious errors, be entitled to recuperate those funds in the case where the decision falls towards his innocence of these charges, through laboratory, government or ADO malfeasance?

Questions unanswered, as of yet...

And furthermore, even more incomprehensively, is this:

If in fact Floyd's Positive AAF is reversed by the AAA Arbitrators' decision, he could be forced to face appeals, by virtue of the WADA CODE, that could or would be lodged not only by the prosecuting Agency USADA, but also from:

b– the French AFLD (if WADA CODE Article 13.2.3, which states “...and any other Anti-Doping Organization under whose rules a sanction could have been imposed;...” is the basis under which AFLD has repetitively announced that it awaits the decision of the USADA arbitration before commencing actions against Floyd on its own),

c– the UCI (doubtfully would they enter the case), and

d– WADA.

Is that clear? Here's an imperfect analogy: if your brother is found 'not guilty' in Minnesota for stealing a car, this WADA CODE provision might allow Wisconsin, Manitoba or Mexico to appeal the case to the Swiss Tribune Federal!

WADA, aka Pound, is dripping with vitriol against Armstrong and Landis: what portion of WADA's annual budget would be subverted into chasing the appeal against Landis?

AFLD, as mentioned, remains bloodthirsty for Landis, and has merely 'extended a courtesy' to its American counterpart – USADA – by delaying their own 'prosecution' until the American Arbitration decision: this potentially allows them a supra-legal status: as initiator of a 'double-jeopardy' attack against Floyd, a potential 'Appellant' in the USADA v Landis case, and as potential 'Appellant' in the potential AFLD v Landis case...

Heavy stuff...

This reeks, with the bile of disgust rising in the throats of above-average sporting-litigation observers.

We wait, pensively...

We don't understand the longevity of deliberations that continue to foster tensions, towards an announcement of this decision, now perhaps the equivalent of a seismic event of 9.9 on the open-ended Richter scale...

Changes, chances...

This fall will bring to a motley end, the First Dominion of WADA, as Dick Pound abandons the scepter of power (and benefits: unlimited First Class Travel to EVERY World Class global sporting event, anti-doping seminars, etc., which more than make up for his 'selfless' choice to draw a salary of 1 Canadian dollar/year). Pound leaves the helm of a ship that is decidedly adrift, and losing the moral support of Athletes.

Scheduled this fall are important redrafting sessions for the WADA CODE, to be held in mid-November, in Madrid, Spain. You can download a REDLINE v2 of the revisions document here.

This session will theoretically address the apparent shortcomings of these Inter-Agency documents, hastily implemented in 2003 and 2004, which have created certain innocent victims, while providing initial steps to global harmonization, an as-yet unattained goal. It would be interesting to ascertain how WADA will seek to reduce the Conflicts-of-Interest created as the WADA CODE superseded the IOC Medical Code, and began funneling 'research funds' to the 34 accredited laboratories.

As Dick Pound leaves WADA in November, a bit sullied, rumours abound that Monsieur Lamour, former French Minister of Sport, will 'win election' to replace him.

Dick... Who had himself hoped that, despite his fury, his belligerence, his bellicosity, and his disregard for his WADA CODE, that his stature would make him a natural, victorious candidate for the Presidency of the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS/TAS). The news from CAS/TAS this summer, however, was for continuation of the appointment of its Interim President, apparently squashing the hopes of Mr. Pound to continuously inflict the world of Sport with his personal 'duty' to create injustice.

Egos? On the line; every day, everywhere, in each press report...

Winners? Displays of the finest and worst definitions of 'winning'...

Losers? Will we ever really know who actually loses, from the Floyd Landis case outcome?

Consequence(s)????


........................................................ ZENmud